Company Value
The wrong words, in the wrong order
‘What does your company do’ should be the easiest question for a CEO to answer, which makes it strange that so few get it right
It is, I have come to realise, the hardest question I ask all day, and it’s usually asked early in the session, well before the first serving of coffee has gone cold. So, what does your company do? The people in the room at our Beyond Borders workshops are not juniors (most are founders, chief executives, sales or marketing directors of IT and outsourcing firms hoping to win, or at least keep, clients overseas) and they have presumably been asked the same thing many, many times. And yet the answers I get, broadly, consist of a long, strikingly similar list of services, or the story of how the company was started, or a sentence in which ‘innovative’ and ‘solutions’ turn up with alarming regularity. Having asked for a couple of sentences, I usually get a verbal essay of many paragraphs, delivered with a smile and much self-satisfaction. When I then say that the question hasn’t really been answered, there’s much consternation throughout the room.
In fairness to the participants (and I do, honestly, try to be fair) they are in good company. In April 2008 David Collis and Michael Rukstad, two strategists at Harvard Business School, called it a dirty little secret that most executives cannot set out the objective, scope, and advantage of their business in a simple statement. They proposed a test of 35 words which, in their experience, very few bosses could honestly pass. Seven years later Donald Sull and Rebecca Homkes asked more than 11,000 senior managers, at over 400 companies, to list their firm’s top priorities, and only a third could name the top three (and these, it should be said, were people one or two steps down the ladder from the CEO). The grim conclusion of all this is that if the very people running a company don’t know or cannot agree on what it is for, then it seems a bit much to expect a potential customer to know either.
If the people running a company don’t know what it does, then it seems a bit much to expect a potential customer to know either.
As nebulous as those answers I usually receive are, they sound both sharp and pertinent in comparison with the vaguely absurd (and highly expensive) version filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission in August 2019 by WeWork. The co-working firm’s IPO prospectus described a “community company” whose mission was nothing less than to elevate the world’s consciousness. It used the word community some 150 times, which is a lot of community for a business that did little more than sign some very long leases on office space and then rented them out, desk by desk, on often rather short leases. It was a landlord, and a loss-making one at that. Its private backers had valued it at 47 billion US dollars, but wiser stock market investors, once they had read the prospectus, talked of perhaps 10 billion US dollars. Just over a month later WeWork pulled the flotation so that the company could concentrate, as its bosses put it, on its “core business”. That is about as close as it gets to admitting that somebody had finally asked what the company actually did.
The crayon test
None of this, of course, is remotely new, and academics who write about management have been going on about it (often at great length) since at least the 1960s. Ted Levitt’s Marketing Myopia, published in the Harvard Business Review in 1960, argued that America’s railways got into trouble because the men running them assumed (not, it must be said, without reason) that they were in the railroad business rather than the transportation business. And so they stood by while lorries, cars, and aeroplanes drove (or flew) off with their customers. Peter Lynch, who ran Fidelity’s Magellan fund for 13 years, told investors never to back an idea they could not illustrate with a crayon. Y Combinator (a start-up accelerator that has seen more start-up pitches than most) warns applicants that its partners are immune to marketing speak. Its application process asks founders to say what their company does in 50 characters or less, a limit that would, forgive the pun, be beyond many of my Beyond Borders workshop participants.
What has changed in the decades since Levitt began banging the What business are you in? drum is who is listening, and how little patience they have. In 2011 Jakob Nielsen, a usability expert, found that visitors decide whether to stay on a web page within about 10 seconds (and most of the homepages I see in workshops use those 10 seconds badly, saying very little about what the company does. See this article). Increasingly, however, potential buyers never even get as far as the homepage at all. In Forrester’s 2025 survey of business buyers, it was generative AI tools that were the single most cited source of useful information when researching a purchase. That means the description of what a company does is now more often than not written by a chatbot, summarising whatever it happens to find. If what it finds is a meaningless word salad, the summary will be meaningless word salad, only shorter and almost certainly better written. A firm that cannot say what it does is, in effect, leaving a machine to guess what it does.
So why is it so hard? Partly, this correspondent suspects, because a good answer often means saying (through omission) what a company does not do. Then there’s the fact that the copy might have been written by a committee (or an agency, or worst of all both), and nobody wanted to be the person who took a stand and crossed out ‘innovative’. And partly, it must be said, because a few firms genuinely (and sadly) do not know what they actually do, having drifted into whatever their last big customer wanted them to do and then stuck with it because they believed that’s where the value now lies.
In our Beyond Borders workshops the better answers, when they eventually arrive (usually from participants who have been taking urgent notes after seeing those who were unfortunate enough to go first try and fail) are beautifully plain and simple. They include a breakdown of what the firm builds, for whom it builds it, and why a client should pick it rather than a company in the office further along the corridor. Rocket science it is not, but far too many get it wrong.
Craig Turp-Balazs is head of insight and analysis at Reinvantage.



