Company Differentiation

First sentence

Take the adjectives off a firm’s homepage and what is left is its real value

Craig Turp-BalazsOctober 16, 20265 min read
Dreamstime

Try this. Open your company’s website and read aloud the first words you see. Then open a competitor’s and do the same, then a third (and a fourth, and a fifth; indeed, as many as you have time to check, quite frankly). Across any number of sectors (consultancies, agencies of all kinds, outsourcers of every stripe, and just about any service from hairdressing to massage) the exercise usually turns out to be at least mildly humiliating, because the words are so often both meaningless and interchangeable. IT firms are probably the biggest culprits. One company is a leading provider of innovative end-to-end digital solutions while another is a trusted, passionate technology partner. Swap the company names at the top of the pages and it’s highly unlikely that anybody (even the people who wrote the pages) will notice.

What follows is where the exercise becomes doubly humiliating. Take out the pointless adjectives, the ‘leading’, ‘innovative’, ‘world-class’, ‘trusted’, and the ‘passionate', and what you are left with is your company’s real positioning, its real value. Alas, very little positioning usually survives the adjective cull. What is usually left is an endless list of services (web, mobile, cloud, apps, AI, ERP, blockchain, and, if you ask nicely, games) that amount to not much more than ‘whatever you need’. And, somewhat depressingly, that is a perfectly honest description of almost any business that hires out engineers by the hour. It is also, increasingly, a highly accurate description of just the kind of business that is most likely to be facing trouble.

Which makes rewriting the first sentence of a company website both the cheapest strategy review a firm will ever do, and (with AI eating the ‘we do everything, cheaper’ model), probably the most urgent. It costs nothing except an afternoon and a few key staff primed with good ideas and honesty. It really doesn’t need a team of consultants (although there is no shortage of charlatans ready to tell you otherwise), no new software, no expenditure, and certainly no restructuring.

What are you good at?

The urgency to get this right, and the pressure on generalists, are both very real. In July, Pzena, an investment manager, concluded that the most exposed IT-services firms are those that do nothing more than rent out (usually cheap) engineering labour, and that money has noticed which way the wind is blowing. Cognizant now earns more than half its revenue from fixed-price and outcome-based contracts, where the client pays for a result rather than for hours, and Accenture said last December that fixed-price work now makes up around 60 per cent of its engagements (up by some ten percentage points in three years).

The problem for the generalists is that it is very difficult, if not impossible, to sell an outcome if you can’t say what it is you are good at. To be honest though, any firm invoicing by the hour never really needed to know (the client decided what the hours were for, and paid for them regardless). But a firm selling outcomes must know which outcomes it can reliably deliver (as well as for whom and at what cost), and then it has to say be able to say so, in plain language, on its website. (And websites, contrary to what some commentators might say, still matter).

For a generation, the pitch of most outsourcers has been roughly the same, namely that they can do good work, cheaper. The reason for that is that it has by and large worked, often because clients simply could not hire enough engineers (or afford to) of their own. The model looks far less stable now, and works rather less well, given that a firm whose main selling point is cheaper hours is competing, in essence, with software that charges next to nothing for its hours at all.

A reinvented outsourcing firm perhaps does fewer things, but it does them well and it does them provably.

This makes differentiation all the more important, but it must also be provable, because buyers check (and, with a search engine, an LLM, and a few minutes, they check thoroughly). Before agreeing to a second meeting, a cautious buyer will look the firm up on LinkedIn, read what former staff say about it and search for anything it would rather they didn’t find. A website promising 200 experts next to a LinkedIn page showing 46 employees is a bit of a giveaway. Nor do the logos of famous multinationals for work actually done as a subcontractor’s subcontractor, or nebulous case studies boasting of “300 per cent efficiency gains for a major European retailer” (whatever that means, and whoever that was) matter anymore. The language used needs to be succinct and (most importantly) verifiable, and it needs to state clearly, up front and centre, exactly what a company does (well) and what value that company can provide.

Basically, that’s what a reinvented outsourcing firm might look like; one that perhaps does fewer things, but does them well and does them provably (and says so on the opening spread of its website). Two or three areas where it is genuinely strong, and can demonstrate why with case studies that make sense (written both for those who understand the sector, as well as those who don’t) that tell of how, for example, invoice processing times were cut from nine days to two, rather than a few vague claims about improvements in efficiency. Certifications that can be verified with whoever issued them, named references willing to take a call or respond to an email, and a headcount that matches LinkedIn.

None of this means turning work away wholesale. A firm that says it specialises in software for logistics companies will still take a decent web project if one comes along, and nobody will think less of it. What changes is what it leads with, what it invests in, whom it hires and what it says no to when its people are stretched, which covers, more or less, everything that matters. That is why it counts as reinvention, even if it starts with just a single sentence.

That first sentence, then, is worth reading aloud again once the adjectives have gone. If it could still belong to any other firm, it’s simply not good enough. Time to make it your own.

Craig Turp-Balazs

Craig Turp-Balazs is head of insight and analysis at Reinvantage.