Pitching Events
No gimmicks please, we want feedback
The most useful thing a pitch event can give a founder is not a prize but an honest verdict
A start-up event where every pitch had to be set to music? Or another where each pitch was made while rotating through the air on a ferris wheel? What about pitching your groundbreaking idea while waist-deep in snow? Or in total darkness? Members of the Reinvantage team have witnessed all of the above, sometimes acting as judges, at others simply as mere bystanders. We don’t recall any of them producing genuinely great ideas, and have entirely forgotten the names of the start-ups made to pitch in such a performative way. Plenty of these events pitched themselves (pun intended) as revolutionary, but delivered very little. We may, admittedly, be working with a relatively small sample but there’s no evidence whatsoever to suggest that such gimmicks are any better than standard pitching events where a founder stands on a stage for five minutes and runs through a deck of slides. Great ideas don’t need gimmicks. They just need to be put in front of the right audience.
Founders, of course, rarely (if ever) ask for gimmicks. None, as far as we know, have ever demanded that they present their brilliant ideas in a cable car or light aircraft. Most are happy with a small room, as long as the right people are in it. The problem is that the gimmick-led start-up event usually generates some great headlines for the people organising it, which is what most are concerned with. What founders themselves might want (or need) is a secondary (if that) concern.
A pitch competition should be designed around the needs of those founders, and of the investors who might be ready to back them, and the best ones still are. They place emphasis on the business model as much as the idea (great ideas do not always translate into viable business models, something our own Andrew Wrobel, a frequent judge at such events, has long advocated) and, importantly, offer feedback. There’s some evidence, indeed, that shows feedback is the most valuable thing a pitch event can offer, not prize money.
In 2017, Sabrina Howell, an economist at New York University’s Stern School of Business, sifted through the judging data from 87 new-venture competitions in America in a paper called Reducing Information Frictions in Venture Capital: The Role of New Venture Competitions. She reported that at 34 of the events founders were (privately) told where they had ranked (rather than just being told they had won, with those who hadn’t left to wonder how they had performed). Her conclusion was that rather than focusing on large cash prizes, competitions might consider directing resources to improving the quality of judging and market signalling. Interestingly, none of the events she looked at made it clear before participants signed up about whether or not feedback would be given. It really shouldn’t be a guessing game. The most valuable thing judges at a pitch event can do is to tell a founder if their idea is worth pursuing. She would later say that receiving negative feedback increases average venture abandonment by 13 per cent, a relatively small percentage that demonstrates how hard it is for start-up founders to let go, something that Reinvantage has long warned about as being a key blockage to reinvention.
At pitch events, what start-ups need far more than applause is somebody willing to tell them the truth early enough for it to be acted upon.
Indeed, little of this will come as a surprise to anybody who has seen large companies reticent about killing off a product line or a programme that has long outlived its purpose. Stopping is the hardest part of reinvention, and the part most often neglected, because somebody has to admit that the time (and money) already spent on something might need to be reallocated. In many ways, it’s the sunk cost fallacy writ large. Start-ups (nimble by definition) should be a lot better at this than larger or better established firms, but a founder who has given two years of their life to an idea is clearly no more rational about these things than a leviathan. At pitch events, what they need far more than applause is somebody willing to tell them the truth early enough for it to be acted upon.
Alas, a founder who has just delivered a pitch from a rotating gondola (or in the middle of a snowdrift, or in the dark) will get applause, maybe a few laughs, and occasionally might even win a prize, but almost never an honest view on whether the idea itself is any good, since there is not a great deal of incentive to offer one. Event organisers chasing good headlines don’t really want the majority of their participants reconsidering their business models during the coffee break.
Which is a shame, not least because founders who are told that they might be barking up the wrong tree are not all then lost to entrepreneurship. Of those in Howell’s sample who abandoned their ventures, 39 per cent went on to found (or at least help run) another start-up. That should be the key piece of learning, that letting go of one idea is often what prompts or simply allows room for the next one to flourish. A founder who walks away from a pitch event knowing that is much better equipped to move on than one who leaves with nothing more than a round of applause, clueless as to how they actually performed, and then wastes another two years developing a non-viable idea. Organisers keen to do some genuine reinventing of their own could do a lot worse than drop the cable car, keep the room small but packed with the right people, and promise every founder (well in advance, preferably) an honest verdict about what they have heard. As for those start-ups we watched pitching their ideas in the snow, we have indeed long since forgotten their names, but we do hope that at least a few of their founders are busy developing something else, something better.
The byline Reinvantage Insight is used to denote articles to which several members of the Reinvantage insight and analysis team may have contributed.



